Philosophy, Theology, History, Science, Big Questions
  • Homepage
    • Collections of Works By Great Thinkers
    • How To Become A Christian
    • Apologetics: Who Need's It
    • Ask ?'s
    • Introduce a New Topic to Discuss
    • Other Recommended Websites / Reading
    • 12 Pitfalls of the Foolish Apologist
    • Apologetics 101: The Basics
  • Phil. Theology
  • Phil. of Religion
    • Arguments for the Existence of God
    • Objections to the Arguments for the Existence of God
    • Defeaters of Divine Hiddenness
    • Defeaters of the Problem of Evil and Divine Silence
    • More Arguments Against Christian Theism
    • The Problem of Miracles
    • Incompatible Properties Argument
    • Reformed Epistemology
    • Molinism
    • Primary Sources On Big Topics In Phil. Of Religion
  • Phil. of Science/Time
    • The Metaphysics of Quantum Mechanics
    • Fine-Tuning is a Fact
    • Absolute Beginnings
    • God/Time/Cosmology
    • Scientific Realism
  • Biblical Studies
    • Substantial New Testament Puzzles (In Progress)
    • Substantial Old Testament Puzzles (In Progress)
    • Evolution and Christianity
    • Rethinking Biblical Inspiration (In Progress)
    • The Gospels: Guilty Until Proven Innocent?
    • The Historical Case for the Resurrection >
      • Objections to the Resurrection
  • Scholarly Naturalism
    • Paul Draper
    • J.L. Schellenberg
    • Gregory Dawes

Does an increase of Gospel miracles help the legend theory?

1/12/2012

0 Comments

 
1) A DIRECT RESPONSE TO PASSION NARRATIVES IS GIVEN HERE BY DAVID WOOD:
barker.docx
File Size: 42 kb
File Type: docx
Download File

2) AN INDIRECT RESPONSE WOULD BE THE FOLLOWING:  The premise of this question is incorrect. John’s Gospel, generally held to be the latest, actually records the fewest miracles of the four canonical gospels. 

It depends on how you count, but the number of miracles in Matthew, Mark and Luke are pretty close. One helpful chart:
miracles_of_jesus.pdf
File Size: 59 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

lists 23 miracles each in Mark and Luke, and 29 in Matthew. Again, John is the outlier with only 10 miracles. By these counts, Mark has the most “miracles per page” of the four (and none of those occur in the disputed verses of chapter 16).

There are many reasons for the differing counts of miracles in the four Gospels. No Gospel author claims to give us a final and exhaustive list. There is considerable overlap between Matthew, Mark and Luke, but each of these authors include miracles that illustrate the themes they bring out from Jesus’ life and ministry. John narrates fewer miracles than any other author, but generally goes into greater detail on each one.

So even if the miracle count did increase in subsequent Gospels (and the order in which they were written is by no means certain), there could be lots of good reasons. As it happens, though, that doesn’t appear to be the case.

Jake Hunt, MDiv Reformed Theological Seminary

3)  Even if an increase in miracles supports the 'legend hypothesis,' it needs to be clearly said that according to A.N. Sherwin White, two generations is too short a time span for the historical hard core of a historical source to be replaced by legend.  Since all of the gospels were written between 1-1.5 generations after the death of Jesus, the hard core of the narrative in the Gospels would not be wiped out (although various secondary details might).  In practical terms, what this would mean is that the crucifixion, burial, empty tomb, post-mortem appearances, and origin of the disciples belief in a bodily resurrected Jesus would be maintained as part of the hard core of what would be retained as historical in the Gospels whereas various secondary details like the number of angels, the various locales and sequence of appearances, whether there was a guard or two at the tomb, and the like may plausibly be excised as legend if one were so persuaded.

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed